The following is a wonderful negation of a member of the Anti-Eruv Cabal. This person is typical of the Cabal; his goal is to vitiate eruvin at any cost. His arguments demonstrate that he objected first and then came up with a reason for doing so afterwards. As I have previously written, to argue that 16 amos negates mechitzos is am haraatzus, as even the Mishkenos Yaakov admits that it is not a shiur pirtzah. As set forth in this takedown, to argue that the Alter Rebbe maintained that 16 amos is a shiur pirtzah is am haraatzus as well. There is no doubt in my mind that the following essay cannot be refuted.
Click on images to enlarge:
